Lindsey Summers had long brown hair, a huge smile, and big brown eyes. To my twelve-year old self, she had everything. There I was at my first middle school dance decked out in my finest khaki pants fresh from the husky aisle at the Duck Head Outlet. I stood in the corner of the gym with all of the other non-dancing young men. I had no intention of stepping on that dance floor despite the blaring Backstreet Boys tunes. I was content to simply stand and think about how beautiful Lindsey was.
Then, the unexpected happened.
While I was minding my own business, Lindsay walked over to my non-dancing crowd.
“Do you want to dance?” she asked.
What?! Why?! She wasn’t supposed to do this!
So, I did what any normal twelve-year old boy would do. I yelled “no,” ran, and hid. I’m not kidding. I literally sprinted away from her and hid. I knew Lindsey was beautiful. I knew I really liked her. I knew “yes” was the right answer. But when the moment of truth came, I screamed “no” and ran. I was afraid to dance.
My “no” pushed me into hiding. I didn’t get an opportunity to dance with Lindsey again. Turns out she isn’t into sprinters... or boys who hid. I don’t think my social life recovered from that one for a few years. Perhaps it’s still recovering. I said “no” a lot when I was younger.
While most of us have outgrown or embraced our social awkwardness, we still find ourselves saying “no” a lot.
We say “no” to our true callings because we doubt our gifts and abilities. We deny opportunities to preach, take initiative in our communities, and lead God’s people. We’ll find another calling. The task at hand is too hard. We don’t know if we’re up to it. We don’t want to be challenged too much, and we certainly don’t
want to risk failure.
We say “no” because we over-think everything. Before we make any decisions about vocation, a sermon, or where we want to go for dinner, we check out fifteen books from the library and ask every mentor we have for their opinions. We are frozen by our lack of confidence in God and ourselves.
We say “no” because the church is too messed up. It fights over things that don’t matter. It spends money on building bigger buildings. We don’t want to be a part of it. We quit going and quit investing. Instead, we’re content with talking and tweeting and blogging about how bad the church is. The church usually doesn’t
look anything like Jesus.
We say “no” because we don’t believe in Jesus. The Kingdom of God is as make-believe as our favorite Disney fairy tale. The resurrection is a hoax. Our faith is in nothing more than pie-in-the-sky talk. Sometimes, we only make ourselves believe because we are so deep into seminary that we don’t know if we have
another option.
I went to a wedding a few months ago on a Sunday afternoon in Lula, Georgia. After the wedding, everyone gathered inside for dinner. Seating was assigned and don’t you know I got seated with those people. You know those people. The ones who, when they hear you’re in a seminary, say things like:
“That’s so nice.” “You must know the Bible really well.” “Do you want to be some sort of preacher?” Or my personal favorite, “I’m so sorry for cussing earlier.”
My roommate, Blake Tommey, was at the wedding too. After finding out his table-mates were much cooler than mine, I changed seats. At his table were two Anglican folks named Isaac and Rebecca. After a few minutes of small talk, they found out Blake and I were in seminary. And these people, unlike the ones at my
table, really knew how to talk to seminarians. They made jokes about Calvinism, church fights, and ministers. We also had some normal conversation - what a novel concept. And, Isaac asked me one question that I’ve been thinking about for a while.
He jokingly asked, “So, you’re in seminary. Do you still believe in Jesus?” After everyone laughed, I answered, “Yes. I still believe in Jesus.” Later that night, I thought about his question again. As I pondered it, I said to myself, “If I would have been completely honest, I should have said, ‘Today,
yes. Sometimes though, no.’”
When I think about the 20 young children killed in Sandy Hook Elementary School or a bomb blasting at the Boston Marathon, I’m likely to say “no.” When I think about the damage Christianity has done in the name of Christ, from the Crusades to modern-day discrimination, I’m likely to say “no.”
When I read book after book and write paper after paper about God without making any effort to interact with God or God’s people, I’m likely to say “no.” Perhaps I am the only one who feels that way, but I’m betting most of us sometimes want to say “no” when we ask ourselves if we believe in Jesus. We may
never say it out loud. We may never even admit it to ourselves. But somewhere deep inside of us, we sometimes want to say “no.”
Peter doesn’t even try to hide his “no.” Or his multiple “nos.” Only a few days before this breakfast on the beach, Peter says “no” to Jesus three times. A woman asks him if he knows Jesus.
Peter says, “No.” A crowd asks Peter if he knows Jesus. Peter says, “No.” A slave asks Peter if he knows Jesus. Peter says, “No. Nope. Not a chance. ”
Shortly after Peter’s third “no,” Jesus is sentenced to death and crucified. A few days later though, he is resurrected, and Jesus appears a few times to his disciples and others. Peter has a chance to see him again.
Peter’s “no” still plagues him though. He can’t sleep due to the nightmares. He feels embarrassed around the other disciples. He was supposed to be the leader! How could he do this? Peter, previously known for being quick to speak and slow to listen, doesn’t say a word to Jesus the first two times he sees him after the
resurrection. His three denials keep playing over and over again in his head.
In an effort to get away, Peter and a few of his friends go to the north shore of the Sea of Galilee, a ways from town. A place that is familiar to them. Peter hops up at night and tells the group, “I’m going fishing. Night fishing is best, and I can’t sleep.”
Peter’s “no” pushes him back to his old way of life. He is running from his call, his identity as a disciple, and Jesus. His “no” has trapped him. Even so, the others agree to go fishing with him. After several hours in the
boat though, these fishermen are striking out. Picture Forest Gump when he first started “shrimping.” Net after net after net catches little more than a few sticks. When daybreak hits, a man starts screaming at them from the beach, “You aren’t catching many fish, are ya?”
They call back, a little agitated, “What does it look like?” while mumbling a few other words under their breaths.
The man offers his unsolicited fishing advice to a group of former professional fishermen, “Try the right side!”
Peter and his crew decide to prove this wise guy wrong. But, they catch so many fish that their nets begin to break.
Then they figure out that the annoying, crazy man on the shore is… Jesus! Peter is naked from diving in the water all night, so he throws on some clothes, leaps into the water, and swims towards Jesus faster than Michael Phelps. It suddenly clicks for Peter. He can’t go back to his old way of life. He can’t let “no” rule his life. He can’t go on with some humdrum existence. The other men follow closely behind him in the boat. When they all get to the shore, Jesus is cooking a breakfast of fish and bread over a nice little fire. The disciples sit down and eat a meal together, something they had done many times.
After breakfast, Jesus decides to quiz Peter.
First question: “Do you love me?” Peter exclaims, “Yes!” without hesitation. “Ok,” Jesus says, “Feed my lambs.” Second question: “Are you sure you love me?” Peter says, “This is easy. Yes!” “Then, tend my sheep,” Jesus commands. Third and final question: “Peter, be honest, do you love me?” This question sure does sound familiar. “Yes!” Peter screams. “This is the last time I’ll tell you, Peter; feed my sheep,” Jesus responds.
Peter said “no” to Jesus three times in the past few days. His “no” had led him back to fishing - his way of life before ever meeting Jesus some three years ago.
Jesus responds to Peter’s three “nos” by giving him three chances to say “yes.” Peter’s “no” haunts him. Jesus helps him let go of “no” and embrace “yes.” But Jesus doesn’t only give Peter a chance to say yes. Jesus reminds him what saying “yes” means. “Yes” means loving people. “Yes” means taking care of
all God’s children. “Yes” means leaning into his identity as a disciple. “Yes” means following his true calling even when fishing seems easier. “Yes” means following Jesus to the cross.
We, too, are able to change our “no” to “yes.” Peter was able to say “yes” as many times as he had said “no.” When we say “no,” we get pushed back into corners, into old ways of life. When we say “yes,” new possibilities arise. We get fresh opportunities to say “yes” even when we think “no” has trapped us. We say “yes” to our true callings because we are confident in our gifts and abilities. We welcome invitations to preach; we take initiative in our communities and lead God’s people. We dive deep into opportunities to practice and explore our callings. The task at hand is not too hard. We are up to it. We want to be
challenged and we certainly want to take risks.
We say “yes” because we quit over-thinking everything. We stop freezing over every single decision we make. We realize that we don’t have to take a class on every possible situation before taking action. Instead, we make some of our own choices and start listening to the Spirit ourselves.
We say “yes” because the church is Christ’s presence on earth. We want to be a part of it. We start going and start investing. We quit simply talking about the church and begin participating in the church. We discover that it stands for justice.
The church loves the unlovable. It builds communities with deeper relationships than those our culture values. The church looks a lot like Jesus.
We say “yes” because we believe in Jesus. We believe the Kingdom of God is more real than this very moment. We live in the light of the resurrection. Jesus has already changed the world. Our faith is in something powerfully true, even when tragedy strikes or when we Christians act like we’ve never heard of Christ.
When we answer “no,” we find a life we can’t really want. A life of the same old, same old. A life lacking meaning or purpose. A life where we live like someone other than who we were created to be.
When we answer “yes,” we find a life we really do want. A life of seeking the Kingdom of God. A life with more purpose and meaning than we can imagine. A life of loving God and loving people. A life of following God’s call, listening to the Spirit, being the church, and believing in Jesus.
We will still say “no” sometimes. In certain seasons, we will say it quite often. “No” cannot plague us though. “No” does not have the last word. “No” is not our final chance. Peter got chances to change his “no” to “yes.” We, too, serve the God who gives us chances to say “yes” again.
May we let our “no” be “yes.”
1 NT Wright, John for Everyone: Chapters 11-21 (Louisville: Westminster John Knox Press, 2004), 156.
----
Rich Havard is a second-year seminary student at McAfee School of Theology. This sermon was preached by him in McAfee Chapel for the John R. Claypool Preaching Award.